Socratic Seminars offer students a unique chance to express their ideas, sharpen critical thinking, and develop leadership skills. When done well, these discussions transform classrooms into vibrant spaces where students engage deeply with texts and each other. If you want to bring this dynamic learning experience to your classroom, follow these three simple steps to set up effective Socratic Seminars that your students will enjoy and benefit from.

Step 1: Select a Thought-Provoking Text and Prepare Questions

The foundation of any Socratic Seminar is the text that sparks discussion. Choose a text that challenges students to think critically and encourages multiple viewpoints. This could be:

• A scholarly article on a current issue

• A piece of literature or a poem with rich themes

• A video that raises ethical or philosophical questions

  
  

At the start, provide students with discussion questions to guide their thinking. These questions should be open-ended and invite analysis rather than simple yes/no answers.

As students grow more comfortable with the format, encourage them to create their own questions. This practice deepens their engagement and ownership of the discussion.

For more ideas on texts, explore collections specifically curated for Socratic Seminars:

Step 2: Teach Essential Discussion Skills

Students need clear guidance on how to participate in a productive discussion. Socratic Seminars are not just about sharing opinions but about listening, building on others’ ideas, and asking thoughtful questions.

One effective way to teach these skills is through the acronym PHOGA:

• Paraphrasing: Restate what someone else said to show understanding.

• Helping: Support others’ ideas by adding relevant points or examples.

• Obstructing: Challenge ideas respectfully to encourage deeper thinking.

• Giving: Offer your own insights clearly and confidently.

• Asking: Pose open-ended questions that invite further discussion.

  
  

Pair this with Celeste Headlee’s TED Talk on conversation skills, which emphasizes listening fully, avoiding multitasking, and being brief and clear.

Set clear norms for your seminar, such as:

• Students speak without raising hands, using a “popcorn” style to keep the flow natural.

• Always refer back to the text to support points.

• Pause occasionally to give everyone time to think.

• Show respect for all contributions, even when disagreeing.

  
  

Model these behaviors yourself and practice them with students before the seminar. Role-playing or watching recorded seminars can help students see these skills in action.

Step 3: Choose an Evaluation Method and Reflect

Evaluating Socratic Seminars helps students understand their strengths and areas for growth. Decide how you want to assess the discussion:

• Self-evaluation: Students reflect on their own participation and set goals for improvement.

• Partner evaluation: Peers provide feedback on each other’s discussion skills.

• Teacher evaluation: You assess the overall quality of the discussion and individual contributions.

  
  

For secondary students, setting communication goals before the seminar can focus their efforts. After the discussion, have students reflect on whether they met those goals.

One effective format is the Fishbowl method, where a small group discusses while others observe and evaluate. This encourages active listening and attention to specific skills like PHOGA. Observers can provide targeted feedback, making the evaluation more meaningful.

Choosing the Right Socratic Seminar Format

Once you have the basics down, pick a format that fits your classroom dynamics:

• Student-Led Fishbowl Discussions: Small groups discuss while others observe, then rotate roles.

• Philosophical Chairs: Students physically move to different sides of the room based on their opinions, encouraging debate.

• Socratic Circles: Inner and outer circles alternate between discussing and observing.

• Whole Class Seminars: The entire class participates in one large discussion.

  
  

Each format offers unique benefits. Fishbowl discussions promote focused skill practice, while whole class seminars allow for broad participation. Try different formats to see what works best for your students.

Download a FREE Guide Here: